UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IIInternational RelationsPractice question

BRICS Expansion and India's Foreign Policy

"BRICS expansion reflects the growing assertiveness of the Global South". Critically examine the opportunities and challenges this presents for India's foreign policy.

Critically examine~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Start by contextualizing the recent BRICS expansion as an assertion of reformed multilateralism by the Global South, linking it to India's constitutional and strategic ethos. Next, analyze the major opportunities this enlarged bloc creates for Indian diplomacy and economic interests. Then, critically examine the geopolitical and strategic challenges it poses, concluding with a balanced way forward emphasizing India's multi-alignment posture.

Model answer

413 words

Introduction

The expansion of BRICS with the induction of Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, and the United Arab Emirates marks a structural shift in international relations, demonstrating the Global South's drive for reformed multilateralism. This pursuit of a rules-based, equitable international order aligns closely with the constitutional directive under Article 51(c) to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations.

Opportunities for India's Foreign Policy

The broadening of BRICS presents several strategic and geo-economic advantages that reinforce India's international stature:

  • Global South Leadership: The expanded platform bolsters India's established role as the 'Voice of the Global South', providing a stronger multilateral forum to push for long-pending reforms in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) and Bretton Woods institutions.
  • Energy and Trade Security: The entry of key West Asian players like the UAE and Iran anchors critical energy corridors and facilitates alternative financial architectures, including local currency settlement mechanisms such as the India-UAE rupee-dirham trade arrangement.
  • Preservation of Strategic Autonomy: Active engagement within an enlarged BRICS preserves India's multi-alignment doctrine, enabling New Delhi to balance its Western partnerships (such as the Quad) with non-Western multilateral platforms.
  • Developmental Financing and Technology Export: Strengthening institutions like the New Development Bank (NDB) allows India to advance sustainable development financing and champion its Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) model across emerging markets.

Challenges and Strategic Dilemmas

Despite its potential, an expanded BRICS introduces significant diplomatic frictions and governance complexities:

  • Anti-Western Polarisation: Efforts by China and Russia to frame BRICS as an overt counterweight to the G7 and Western-led institutions threaten to complicate India's burgeoning strategic and technology partnerships with Western democracies.
  • Sinocentric Dilution of Influence: A wider membership risks diluting India's institutional leverage, while simultaneously broadening Beijing's geopolitical orbit and economic dominance within the grouping.
  • Internal Divergences and Cohesion Deficits: Deep-seated bilateral rivalries among newer members, along with a lack of institutional consensus on critical issues such as state-sponsored cross-border terrorism and comprehensive UNSC expansion, hinder cohesive collective action.

Way Forward

To navigate these dynamics, India must continue to advocate for BRICS as a 'non-Western, not anti-Western' platform. By steering the agenda toward public goods, South-South developmental cooperation, and financial resilience, India can protect its core strategic autonomy while preventing the grouping from becoming a vehicle for bloc confrontation.

Conclusion

BRICS expansion offers India a vital platform to reshape global governance in favor of the developing world. To maximize its strategic dividends, India must adeptly balance its non-Western and Western engagements, ensuring the grouping remains focused on equitable multipolarity rather than ideological polarization.

Key facts to remember

definition
Reformed Multilateralism

The diplomatic agenda advocating structural overhauls in premier global governance architectures, including the UN Security Council, IMF, and World Bank, to reflect contemporary geopolitical realities.

example
Local Currency Trade Mechanism (India-UAE)

The operationalization of the Local Currency Settlement System between India and the UAE enables bilateral trade in rupees and dirhams, minimizing dollar dependency within the expanded BRICS framework.

scheme
Article 51(c) of the Constitution of India

A Directive Principle of State Policy obligating the State to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations in the dealings of organized peoples with one another.

Frequently asked questions

How does India position its engagement in BRICS vis-à-vis the West?

India maintains a doctrine of multi-alignment, characterizing BRICS as 'non-Western' rather than 'anti-Western' to safeguard its constructive ties with Western partners like the Quad while advocating Global South reforms.