Dalvoy Logo
Dalvoy
UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IIIIndian EconomyPractice question

Merchandise Exports and Import Intensity in India

"Rising merchandise exports cannot by themselves ensure external-sector resilience when production remains import-intensive." Critically examine with reference to India.

Critically examine~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce with recent trends in India's merchandise exports versus trade deficit to highlight the paradox of export growth with persistent external vulnerability. Analyze the structural limitations of import-intensive export manufacturing, balance this with the strategic role of intermediate imports in global value chains and external cushions, and conclude with policy measures for domestic value addition.

Model answer

417 words

Introduction

India's merchandise exports touched approximately $437 billion in FY25, yet the merchandise trade deficit remained persistently high, surpassing $280 billion. This divergence demonstrates that gross export gains do not automatically translate into external-sector stability when domestic manufacturing relies heavily on imported intermediate inputs, capital goods, and critical raw materials.

Structural Vulnerabilities of Import-Intensive Export Production

When domestic manufacturing remains heavily reliant on imported intermediate inputs, rising headline exports mask deep macroeconomic vulnerabilities:

  • Low Net Foreign Exchange Retention: In high-growth sectors such as electronics assembly, domestic value addition remains modest at approximately 15% to 20%. The bulk of export earnings is expended on importing printed circuit boards, integrated circuits, and components, limiting net foreign exchange accretion.
  • Critical Input Dependencies and Supply Chain Bottlenecks: India’s pharmaceutical formulation exports depend on China for around 70% of their Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs). Similarly, refined petroleum products constitute a major export segment but require importing more than 85% of crude oil inputs. Any global supply disruption or geopolitical friction instantly threatens domestic export output and trade balances.
  • Exchange Rate Depreciation Neutralisation: Classical trade theory suggests currency depreciation boosts export competitiveness. However, when intermediate inputs are imported, currency depreciation raises the landed cost of production, offsetting price advantages and propagating imported domestic inflation.

The Nuance: Strategic Role of Intermediate Imports

While import intensity presents short-term vulnerabilities, it also plays a functional role in international trade dynamics:

  • Global Value Chain (GVC) Integration: Modern industrial production relies on fragmented cross-border supply chains. Seamless access to competitive, high-technology foreign inputs is an indispensable prerequisite for integrating domestic industry into GVCs before backward integration can occur.
  • External Buffers Beyond Merchandise: India's overall external resilience is structurally anchored by strong invisible earnings, including a robust services trade surplus exceeding $180 billion and resilient inbound remittances exceeding $120 billion, which cushion the current account deficit.

Policy Imperatives for Sustainable External Resilience

To convert gross merchandise export expansion into durable external strength, focused domestic reforms are necessary:

  • Upstream Domestic Value Addition: Deepen backward linkages through targeted Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes for component manufacturing, the development of Bulk Drug Parks, and the execution of the India Semiconductor Mission.
  • Tariff and Duty Rationalisation: Correct inverted duty structures that impose higher tariffs on intermediate inputs than finished goods, which discourages domestic manufacturing of capital and intermediate inputs.

Conclusion

Achieving true external-sector resilience requires transitioning from low-value assembly to high-value-added domestic manufacturing. Complementing export-promotion drives with deep backward integration, tariff rationalisation, and resilient service-sector linkages will insulate India's balance of payments from external shocks.

Key facts to remember

statistic

Domestic value addition in India's smartphone and electronics manufacturing sector stands at approximately 15% to 20%, with the remainder accounted for by imported sub-assemblies and components.

— NITI Aayog / Industry Estimates
statistic

India imports roughly 70% of its total Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs) requirements from China to sustain its generic formulation export industry.

— Department of Pharmaceuticals
definition
Inverted Duty Structure

A taxation anomaly where customs duties on imported raw materials or intermediate inputs are higher than the duty on the finished manufactured product, penalising domestic value addition.

scheme
Production Linked Incentive (PLI) for Bulk Drugs

A scheme designed to reduce import dependence on critical Key Starting Materials (KSMs), drug intermediates, and Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients by incentivising domestic manufacturing capacity.

Frequently asked questions

Why does high gross merchandise export not automatically strengthen the trade balance?

When exported commodities rely heavily on imported inputs—such as crude oil for petroleum refining or imported components for mobile assembly—export gains are offset by corresponding import outflows, resulting in limited net foreign exchange earnings.

← All questions on this topic (121)