Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
Political decentralisation, exemplified by India's Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Urban Local Bodies (ULBs), is a cornerstone of democratic governance, aiming to bring decision-making closer to the people. A pivotal step in this direction was the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts of 1992, which mandated a one-third reservation (later increased to 50% in several states) for women in these local bodies. This landmark legislation was intended to empower women, traditionally excluded from formal political spheres, and ensure their voice in grassroots development. While these amendments have led to a significant increase in women's representation, bringing over 1.45 million elected women representatives (EWRs) into governance, their meaningful participation continues to face a myriad of systemic impediments.
Despite the constitutional mandate for women's reservation in local self-governance, a range of obstacles, deeply rooted in socio-cultural, economic, political, and institutional structures, hinder their full and effective participation in the process of political decentralisation. These impediments often reduce elected women representatives to mere figureheads, undermining the spirit of the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments.
Socio-Cultural Impediments
- Patriarchal Mindset and Gender Stereotypes: Deep-rooted patriarchal norms often assign women traditional roles confined to household duties, discouraging their active involvement in public life. This societal mindset views male leadership as superior, leading to resistance, discrimination, and limited community support for women leaders. Studies in Western Odisha, for instance, highlight how traditional expectations restrict women's mobility and access to public spaces for meetings and interactions.
- "Sarpanch Pati" Syndrome: This pervasive phenomenon refers to instances where male family members (husbands, fathers, brothers) of elected women representatives act as de facto decision-makers, reducing the elected woman to a proxy. The Ministry of Panchayati Raj panel recently identified this as a significant challenge, prevalent in states like Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Bihar.
- Purdah System and Limited Mobility: In many rural areas, the purdah system and conservative cultural norms restrict women's physical mobility, limiting their ability to attend meetings, interact with constituents, or visit project sites, thereby hindering their effective functioning.
- Dual Burden of Work and Household Responsibilities: Women elected representatives often struggle to balance their political duties with extensive domestic responsibilities, including childcare and household chores. This dual burden leaves them with limited time and energy to dedicate to governance issues.
- Gender-Based Violence and Threats: Women in politics, particularly in rural settings, frequently face intimidation, verbal abuse, harassment, and even physical violence from opposing politicians or dominant groups. Such threats can coerce them into resigning or discourage active participation.
- Low Levels of Education and Awareness: Many women, especially in rural areas, have limited access to quality education, which can undermine their confidence, skills, and understanding of political processes, governance structures, and their rights and responsibilities.
Economic Impediments
- Financial Dependence and Lack of Economic Empowerment: Most rural women are economically dependent on male family members, which restricts their autonomy and ability to function independently in politics. Limited access to personal financial resources and credit facilities further exacerbates this dependence.
- Lack of Funds for Development Work: Many women sarpanches report a lack of government funding for development projects, which limits their ability to deliver on promises and demonstrate effective leadership, thereby impacting their credibility and motivation.
- Limited Access to Training and Resources: Financial constraints can prevent women from attending necessary training programs, workshops, or accessing information vital for political involvement.
Political and Institutional Impediments
- Lack of Political Training and Awareness: Many elected women representatives enter public life without prior political experience or adequate knowledge of governance structures, financial planning, and policy implementation. Insufficient and untimely training programmes further compound this issue.
- Resistance from Bureaucracy and Male Counterparts: Women leaders often face insensitivity and non-cooperation from bureaucrats and male colleagues who may not take them seriously, assuming a lack of competence. This can lead to delays in fund allocation and scheme implementation.
- Rotational Reservation System: While ensuring broader representation over time, the rotation of reserved seats every five years can be a barrier for women to gain sufficient experience, establish themselves as leaders, and ensure continuity in governance, thereby weakening their long-term political impact.
- Weak Legal Deterrence against Proxy Leadership: Existing legal provisions to penalise male relatives acting as proxies for elected women are often insufficient, allowing the practice to continue unchecked.
- Lack of Women at Higher Levels: The absence of women in higher administrative and political echelons can also hinder the free functioning and upward mobility of women representatives at the local level.
- Political Pressure and "No-Confidence Motions": Women representatives, particularly those from marginalized communities, may face undue political pressure and the misuse of "No-Confidence Motions" as a tactic to remove them from office.
- Digital Divide: In an increasingly digital governance landscape, many women, especially from rural or marginalized backgrounds, lack access to digital devices, internet connectivity, and digital literacy. This excludes them from e-governance tools, online training, and information systems.
Table: Key Challenges Faced by Elected Women Representatives (EWRs)
| Category of Impediment | Specific Challenge |
|---|---|
| Socio-Cultural | "Sarpanch Pati" syndrome, Patriarchal mindset, Purdah system |
| Economic | Financial dependence, Lack of own funds for development |
| Political/Institutional | Lack of training, Bureaucratic resistance, Rotational reservation |
| Personal | Dual burden of household and political work, Lack of confidence due to low education |
These multifaceted impediments collectively undermine the potential of women's participation in local governance, preventing them from fully exercising their constitutional authority and contributing to inclusive development.
Conclusion
The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments marked a paradigm shift in Indian democracy, enabling millions of women to enter the political mainstream. However, the journey from numerical representation to substantive participation remains arduous. The impediments—ranging from deep-seated patriarchal norms, economic dependency, and political tokenism to institutional apathy and lack of capacity building—create a complex web of challenges. Addressing these issues requires a multi-pronged approach encompassing robust legal frameworks against proxyism, comprehensive gender sensitisation, targeted capacity-building, fostering economic independence, and bridging the digital divide. Empowering women in local governance is not merely about gender equality; it is fundamental to strengthening democratic decentralisation and achieving equitable and sustainable development across India.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.