Examine the following statements: 1. All colours are pleasant. 2. Some colours are pleasant. 3. No colour is pleasant. 4. Some colours are not pleasant. Given that statement 4 is true, what can be definitely concluded?
- A1 and 2 are true
- B3 is true
- C2 is false
- D1 is falseCorrect
Explanation
The question asks us to deduce what can be definitely concluded if statement 4 is true.
Let's analyze the statements:
- All colours are pleasant. (Universal Affirmative - A)
- Some colours are pleasant. (Particular Affirmative - I)
- No colour is pleasant. (Universal Negative - E)
- Some colours are not pleasant. (Particular Negative - O)
These are standard categorical propositions. The key relationship here is contradiction.
- Statement 1 (A) and Statement 4 (O) are contradictory propositions. This means if one is true, the other must be false, and vice-versa.
- Statement 3 (E) and Statement 2 (I) are contradictory propositions. This means if one is true, the other must be false, and vice-versa.
Given: Statement 4 "Some colours are not pleasant" is true.
Now let's evaluate the options:
A) 1 and 2 are true Since statement 4 (O) is true, its contradictory, statement 1 (A), must be false. Therefore, option A cannot be correct as it claims 1 is true.
B) 3 is true If statement 4 (O) "Some colours are not pleasant" is true, it does not necessarily mean statement 3 (E) "No colour is pleasant" is true. For example, if some colours are pleasant and some are not, then O is true but E is false. So, 3 is not definitely true.
C) 2 is false If statement 4 (O) "Some colours are not pleasant" is true, it does not necessarily mean statement 2 (I) "Some colours are pleasant" is false. Both can be true (e.g., if out of 10 colours, 5 are pleasant and 5 are not). So, 2 is not definitely false.
D) 1 is false Statement 1 "All colours are pleasant" (A) and Statement 4 "Some colours are not pleasant" (O) are contradictory. Since statement 4 is given as true, its contradictory, statement 1, must be false. This is a definite conclusion.
The final answer is $\boxed{D}$

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
In a group of six women, there are four tennis players, four postgraduates in Sociology, one postgraduate in Commerce and three bank employees. Vimala and Kamla are the bank employees while Amala and …
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
Consider the given statement and the two conclusions that follow: Statement: Morning walk is good for health. Conclusions: 1. All healthy people go for morning walk. 2. Morning walk is essential for m…
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
In a test, Randhir obtained more marks than the total marks obtained by Kunal and Debu. The total marks obtained by Kunal and Shankar are more than those of Randhir. Sonal obtained more marks than Sha…
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
No supporters of 'party X', who knew Z and supported his campaign strategy, agreed for the alliance with 'party Y'; but some of them had friends in 'party Y'. With reference to the above information, …
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
No supporters of 'party X', who knew Z and supported his campaign strategy, agreed for the alliance with 'party Y'; but some of them had friends in 'party Y'. With reference to the above information, …
- Prelims 2017CSATLogical Reasoning
Consider the following: Statement: Good voice is a natural gift but one has to keep practising to improve and well in the field of music. Conclusions: I. Natural gifts need nurturing and care. II. Eve…