UPSC Prelims 2017·CSAT·Reading Comprehension·Passage Comprehension

Disruption of traditional institutions, identifications and loyalties is likely to lead to ambivalent situations. It is possible that some people may renew their identification with traditional groups whereas others align themselves with new groups and symbols emergent from processes of political development. In addition, political development tends to foster group awareness of a variety of class, tribe, region, clan, language, religion, occupation and others. Which among the following is the most logical, rational and critical inference that can be made from the above passage?

Dalvoy logo
Reviewed by Dalvoy
UPSC Civil Services preparation
Last updated 23 May 2026, 3:31 pm IST
  1. AEmergence of powerful mass leaders is essential to create sub-national political entities and thus ensure successful devolution and decentralization.
  2. BThe upper tier of government should impose devolution and decentralization on the regional communities by law or otherwise.
  3. CDevolution, to be successful, requires a democracy in which there is free expression of the will of the people at lower level and their active participation at the grassroots level.Correct
  4. DFor devolution to take place, a strong feeling of regionalism in the masses is essential.

Explanation

The passage describes a society where traditional institutions are disrupted, leading to ambivalent situations. People either renew traditional ties or align with new groups. Crucially, political development fosters awareness based on a variety of identities like class, tribe, region, language, religion, and occupation. Let's analyze the options: A) Emergence of powerful mass leaders is essential to create sub-national political entities and thus ensure successful devolution and decentralization. The passage focuses on societal shifts and group identities, not on the necessity of powerful mass leaders for devolution. This is an external concept not directly supported as an essential condition by the passage. B) The upper tier of government should impose devolution and decentralization on the regional communities by law or otherwise. The passage describes a complex, evolving societal landscape where various identities emerge. Imposing devolution from above would contradict the idea of accommodating diverse group awareness and the implied need for bottom-up engagement. C) Devolution, to be successful, requires a democracy in which there is free expression of the will of the people at lower level and their active participation at the grassroots level. This option directly addresses how devolution can succeed in the context described by the passage. If traditional loyalties are disrupted, new groups and identities emerge, and group awareness is fostered across various lines (class, tribe, region, etc.), then for power transfer (devolution) to be successful, it must allow these diverse groups and individuals to express their will and actively participate. This ensures that devolution responds to the actual needs and aspirations arising from the societal changes. D) For devolution to take place, a strong feeling of regionalism in the masses is essential. The passage mentions "region" as one among many bases for group awareness (class, tribe, clan, language, religion, occupation, and others). It does not single out regionalism as the sole or primary essential factor. The passage presents a much broader and more complex picture of identity formation. Therefore, C is the most logical inference because it provides a mechanism for devolution to effectively navigate the complex and diverse societal landscape described in the passage, where various identities and loyalties are in flux and asserting themselves.
Reading Comprehension: Disruption of traditional institutions, identifications and loyalties is likely to lead to ambivalent situations. It is

Related questions

More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.