Consider the following Statements and Conclusions: Statements: 1. Some rats are cats. 2. Some cats are dogs. 3. No dog is a cow. Conclusions: I. No cow is a cat. II. No dog is a rat. III. Some cats are rats. Which of the above conclusions is/are drawn from the statements?
- AI, II and III
- BOnly I and II
- COnly IIICorrect
- DOnly II and III
Explanation
The problem requires us to determine which conclusions logically follow from the given statements. Let's analyze each conclusion:
Statements:
- Some rats are cats.
- Some cats are dogs.
- No dog is a cow.
Conclusion I: No cow is a cat. From statement 3, we know that dogs and cows are completely separate (No dog is a cow). From statement 2, we know that some cats are dogs. This means there's an overlap between cats and dogs. However, we cannot conclude anything definitive about the relationship between all cats and cows. While the cats that are dogs are not cows, there could be other cats that are not dogs, and these cats could be cows. The statements do not provide enough information to establish that no cow is a cat. Therefore, this conclusion is not necessarily true.
Conclusion II: No dog is a rat. From statement 1, some rats are cats. From statement 2, some cats are dogs. We have an overlap between rats and cats, and an overlap between cats and dogs. However, these "some" relationships do not guarantee that there is no overlap between rats and dogs. It's possible that the "some cats" that are rats are also among the "some cats" that are dogs, leading to some rats being dogs. Conversely, it's also possible they are entirely separate groups. Since we cannot definitively conclude "No dog is a rat," this conclusion is not necessarily true.
Conclusion III: Some cats are rats. Statement 1 directly says: "Some rats are cats." If "Some rats are cats," it logically and necessarily follows that "Some cats are rats." This is a direct and valid immediate inference.
Based on the analysis, only Conclusion III is drawn from the statements.
The final answer is C) Only III

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
In a school, 60% students play cricket. A student who does not play cricket, plays football. Every football player has got a two-wheeler. Which of the following conclusions cannot be drawn from the ab…
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
Directions for the following 2 (two) items: Read the following statements SI and S2 and answer the two items that follow: S1: Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Roha…
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
Read the following statements SI and S2 and answer the two items that follow: SI: Twice the weight of Sohan is less than the weight of Mohan or that of Rohan. S2: Twice the weight of Rohan is greater …
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
Mr 'X' has three children. The birthday of the first child falls on the 5th Monday of April, that of the second one falls on the 5th Thursday of November. On which day is the birthday of his third chi…
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
A five-storeyed building with floors from I to V is painted using four different colours and only one colour is used to paint a floor. Consider the following statements: 1. The middle three floors are…
- Prelims 2019CSATLogical Reasoning
If every alternative letter of the English alphabet from B onwards (including B) is written in lower case (small letters) and the remaining letters are capitalized, then how is the first month of the …