UPSC Prelims 2015·CSAT·Reading Comprehension·Passage Comprehension

Our municipal corporation are understaffed. The issue of skills and competencies of the staff poses an even greater challenge. Urban service delivery and infrastructure are complex to plan and execute. They require a high degree of specialization and professionalism. The current framework within which municipal employees, including senior management, are recruited does not adequately factor in the technical and managerial competencies required. Cadre and recruitment rules only specify the bare minimum in academic qualifications. There is no mention of managerial or technical competencies, or of relevant work experience. This is the case with most municipal corporations. They also suffer from weak organisation design and structure. Which among the following in the most logical and rational assumption that can be made from the above passage?

Dalvoy logo
Reviewed by Dalvoy
UPSC Civil Services preparation
Last updated 23 May 2026, 3:31 pm IST
  1. AThe task of providing urban servicing is a complex issue which requires the organizational expansion of municipal bodies all over the country
  2. BOur cities can provide better quality of life if our local government bodies have adequate staff with required skills and competenciesCorrect
  3. CLack of skilled staff is due to the absence of institutions which offer the requisite skills in city management
  4. DOur country is not taking advantage of the demographic dividend to manage the problems associated with rapid urbanization.

Explanation

The passage details the problems faced by municipal corporations: understaffing, lack of staff skills and competencies, complex urban service delivery, inadequate recruitment rules, and weak organizational design. It implicitly argues that these deficiencies hinder effective urban service delivery. Let's analyze each option: A) The task of providing urban servicing is a complex issue which requires the organizational expansion of municipal bodies all over the country. While the passage states urban servicing is complex, it focuses on the *quality* and *competencies* of staff and organizational design, not necessarily the *expansion* (meaning increasing the number or size) of municipal bodies themselves. Expansion is not the primary solution implied for the stated problems. B) Our cities can provide better quality of life if our local government bodies have adequate staff with required skills and competencies. This is the most logical assumption. The entire passage highlights the current problems (understaffing, lack of skills/competencies, poor recruitment) and the negative impact on urban service delivery. The underlying assumption is that if these problems were rectified – i.e., if there were adequate staff with the right skills – then urban service delivery would improve, leading to a better quality of life in cities. This directly addresses the core issues raised. C) Lack of skilled staff is due to the absence of institutions which offer the requisite skills in city management. The passage attributes the lack of skilled staff to inadequate recruitment rules and weak organizational design, which do not factor in technical and managerial competencies. It does not state or imply that the *reason* for this lack is the absence of training institutions. The problem is with the recruitment framework, not necessarily the availability of training. D) Our country is not taking advantage of the demographic dividend to manage the problems associated with rapid urbanization. The passage does not mention "demographic dividend" at all. While it discusses problems associated with urbanization (complex service delivery), it does not link these to the demographic structure of the country. This introduces an external concept not discussed or implied in the passage. Therefore, B is the most logical and rational assumption as it directly addresses the core problem identified in the passage and proposes the intended positive outcome if those problems were resolved.
Reading Comprehension: Our municipal corporation are understaffed. The issue of skills and competencies of the staff poses an even greater chal

Related questions

More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.