"By liberty I mean the eager maintenance of that atmosphere in which men have the opportunity to be their best selves." Which one of the following expresses the view implied in the above statement?
- ALiberty is the absence of restraint on human action
- BLiberty is what law permits people to perform
- CLiberty is the ability to do what one desires
- DLiberty is the maintenance of conditions for the growth of human personality.Correct
Explanation
The statement defines liberty as the active creation and preservation of an environment where individuals can achieve their full potential ("be their best selves").
A) Liberty is the absence of restraint on human action: This is a negative conception of liberty (freedom from interference). The statement implies a more positive role – the active "maintenance of that atmosphere" for growth, not just the absence of restrictions.
B) Liberty is what law permits people to perform: This ties liberty solely to legal frameworks. The statement speaks of a broader "atmosphere" and "opportunity" for self-development, which goes beyond mere legal permissions.
C) Liberty is the ability to do what one desires: This is too broad and doesn't capture the essence of "best selves," which implies a normative or developmental aspect rather than just any desire. It also misses the "maintenance of atmosphere" part.
D) Liberty is the maintenance of conditions for the growth of human personality: This perfectly aligns with the statement. "Maintenance of conditions" directly reflects "eager maintenance of that atmosphere," and "growth of human personality" directly corresponds to having the "opportunity to be their best selves." This option captures the positive and developmental aspect of liberty emphasized in the statement.

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
Human history abounds in claims and theories confining the right of governing to a few select citizens. Exclusion of the many is justified on the ground that human beings may be rightfully segregated …
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
By 2050, the Earth's population will likely have swelled from seven to nine billion people. To fill all those stomachs while accounting for shifting consumption patterns, climate change, and a finite …
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
Many people in India feel that if we cut our defence expenditure on weapon- building, we can create a climate of peace with our neighbours, subsequently reducing the conflict or creating a no- war sit…
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
India accounts for nearly a fifth of the world's child deaths. In terms of numbers, it is the highest in the world - nearly 16 lakhs every year. Of these, more than half die in the first month of life…
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
Foods travel more than the people who eat them. Grocery stores and supermarkets are loaded with preserved and processed foods. This, however, often leads to environmental threats, such as pollution ge…
- Prelims 2015CSATReading Comprehension
I must say that, beyond occasionally exposing me to laughter, my constitutional shyness has been of no disadvantage whatever. In fact I can see that, on the contrary, it has been all to my advantage. …