UPSC Prelims 2019·CSAT·Logical Reasoning·Arrangement and Puzzles

Six students A, B, C, D, E and F appeared in several tests. Either C or F scores the highest. Whenever C scores the highest, then E scores the least. Whenever F scores the highest, B scores the least. In all the tests they got different marks; D scores higher than A, but they are close competitors; A scores higher than B; C scores higher than A. 48. If F stands second in the ranking, then the position of B is

Dalvoy logo
Reviewed by Dalvoy
UPSC Civil Services preparation
Last updated 8 Jul 2026, 4:39 pm IST
  1. A3rd
  2. B4th
  3. C5thCorrect
  4. D6th

Explanation

The problem requires us to deduce the ranking of six students based on a set of conditions and a specific scenario.

Let's list the given information: Students: A, B, C, D, E, F They all got different marks.

Conditions:

  1. Either C or F scores the highest (1st position).
  2. If C is 1st, then E is 6th (least).
  3. If F is 1st, then B is 6th (least).
  4. D > A (D scores higher than A).
  5. D and A are close competitors (implies they are likely adjacent or very close in rank).
  6. A > B (A scores higher than B).
  7. C > A (C scores higher than A).

Scenario for the question: F stands second in the ranking (F = 2nd).

Step-by-step deduction:

  1. Given F = 2nd.
  2. From condition 1 ("Either C or F scores the highest"), since F is 2nd and not 1st, C MUST be 1st. So, C = 1st.
  3. From condition 2 ("Whenever C scores the highest, then E scores the least"), since C is 1st, E MUST be 6th. So, E = 6th.

At this point, we have:

  1. C
  2. F ... ... ...
  3. E

The remaining students are A, B, D. The remaining positions are 3rd, 4th, 5th.

Now let's use the remaining conditions involving A, B, D: 4. D > A 6. A > B 7. C > A (This is consistent with C being 1st and A being lower).

Combining D > A and A > B, we get the order D > A > B. We need to place D, A, B into positions 3, 4, 5 in this specific order. The only way to do this is: D = 3rd A = 4th B = 5th

This also satisfies condition 5 (D and A are close competitors) as they are 3rd and 4th.

So the complete ranking is:

  1. C
  2. F
  3. D
  4. A
  5. B
  6. E

The question asks for the position of B. Based on our deduction, B is 5th.

Final Answer Check: All conditions are met:

  • C is 1st, F is 2nd (C is highest, consistent with cond 1).
  • C is 1st, E is 6th (consistent with cond 2).
  • F is 2nd, so cond 3 (F highest implies B least) is not applicable.
  • D (3rd) > A (4th) (consistent with cond 4).
  • D and A are close (3rd and 4th, consistent with cond 5).
  • A (4th) > B (5th) (consistent with cond 6).
  • C (1st) > A (4th) (consistent with cond 7).

The position of B is 5th.

The final answer is C

Logical Reasoning: Six students A, B, C, D, E and F appeared in several tests. Either C or F scores the highest. Whenever C scores the high

Related questions

More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.