Passage: Cattle from the nearby villages came to the common ground to graze, and there was still a cool freshness in the air. Hori took several deep breaths and thought of sitting down for a while, since he'd be dying of heat in the scorching 'loo' wind the rest of the day. A number of farmers were eager to lease this bit of land and had offered a good price, but Rai Sahib—God bless him—had plainly told them it was reserved for grazing and would not be relinquished for any price. If he'd been one of those selfish Zamindars, he'd have said the cattle could go to hell, that there was no reason for him to miss the chance to make a little money. But the Rai Sahib still held to the old values, feeling that any landlord who didn't look after his tenants was less than human. Question: Which of the following statements are not correct? 1. The landholdings of Rai Sahib were currently not being used for farming. 2. Temperamentally, Rai Sahib was as greedy as other landlords. 3. It cannot be ascertained that Rai Sahib could have made some money by leasing out the grazing land. 4. It may be asserted that Rai Sahib valued his tenants and wanted to protect their livelihood. Select the answer using the code given below.
- A1 and 2 only
- B1 and 3 only
- C3 and 4
- D1, 2 and 3Correct
Explanation
The correct answer is Option D. The question asks to identify the statements that are not correct. The excerpt is drawn from Munshi Premchand's classic 1936 Hindi novel Godaan (widely known in English through Gordon C. Roadarmel's 1968 translation, The Gift of a Cow), capturing the protagonist Hori's reflections on his landlord, Rai Sahib.
Here is the statement-by-statement analysis:
- Statement 1 is incorrect: The passage notes that only "this bit of land" (the common ground) was reserved for grazing. It does not state that all of Rai Sahib's landholdings were unused for farming. The fact that "farmers were eager to lease" the plot indicates active agriculture elsewhere.
- Statement 2 is incorrect: The text explicitly contrasts Rai Sahib with "selfish Zamindars" who would exploit every opportunity for profit. By stating he "held to the old values," the author clarifies that Rai Sahib was not temperamentally greedy.
- Statement 3 is incorrect: The passage clearly establishes that farmers had "offered a good price" and that leasing the land was a "chance to make a little money." Therefore, it certainly can be ascertained that Rai Sahib could have profited financially.
- Statement 4 is a correct statement: The text notes that Rai Sahib felt any landlord "who didn't look after his tenants was less than human," confirming his protective attitude towards their livelihood.
Because statements 1, 2, and 3 are factually contradicted by the passage, Option D is the correct choice.
Takeaway: In CSAT reading comprehension, always anchor your inferences strictly to the text provided. Pay close attention to negative directives such as "not correct," as overlooking them is a frequent error.

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: HMPV causes milder illness with deaths being very rare and with no long-term post-viral symptoms. Question: Which of the following reflect the intent of the writer in the above passage? 1. To…
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: India is starting to deploy AI for critical use cases such as weather forecasting, pest detection and control, and crop yield optimisation. However, penetration is limited to a small subset o…
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: India is starting to deploy AI for critical use cases such as weather forecasting, pest detection and control, and crop yield optimisation. However, penetration is limited to a small subset o…
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: Previous waves of customer-service technology, including email and those pesky voice menus, stoked concerns of job losses, only for them to fail to materialise. AI could yet prove different. …
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: Cattle from the nearby villages came to the common ground to graze, and there was still a cool freshness in the air. Hori took several deep breaths and thought of sitting down for a while, si…
- Prelims 2026CSATother
Passage: Was it the sun-dappled ambience, the strawberries and cream, the frustration of Flavio Cobolli's unforced errors against Serbian Novak Djokovic on Centre Court or simply the crushing weight o…