UPSC Prelims 2019·CSAT·Reading Comprehension·Passage Comprehension

A majority of the TB infected in India are poor and lack sufficient nutrition, suitable housing and have little understanding of prevention. TB then devastates families, makes the poor poorer, particularly affects women and children, and leads to ostracisation and loss of employment. The truth is that even if TB does not kill them, hunger and poverty will. Another truth is that deep-seated stigma, lack of counselling, expensive treatment and lack of adequate support from providers and family, coupled with torturous side-effects demotivate patients to continue treatment — with disastrous health consequences. Which one of the following is the most logical, rational and crucial message conveyed by the above passage?

Dalvoy logo
Reviewed by Dalvoy
UPSC Civil Services preparation
Last updated 23 May 2026, 3:31 pm IST
  1. ATB is not a curable disease in Indian circumstances
  2. BCuring TB requires more than diagnosis and medical treatmentCorrect
  3. CGovernment's surveillance mechanism is deficient; and poor people have no access to treatment
  4. DIndia will be free from diseases like TB only when its poverty alleviation programmes are effectively and successfully implemented.

Explanation

The passage describes how TB is not just a medical issue but is deeply intertwined with socio-economic factors (poverty, nutrition, housing), psychological barriers (stigma, lack of counselling), and systemic support issues (expensive treatment, lack of support, side-effects). It highlights that these non-medical factors often demotivate patients from continuing treatment, leading to disastrous health consequences. A) TB is not a curable disease in Indian circumstances. This is incorrect. The passage does not state that TB is incurable. Instead, it details the *challenges* in successfully treating it due to various barriers, implying that if these barriers are overcome, treatment can be successful. B) Curing TB requires more than diagnosis and medical treatment. This option perfectly encapsulates the passage's main message. The passage explicitly lists numerous factors beyond just medical diagnosis and treatment (like nutrition, housing, prevention understanding, stigma, counselling, support, cost, side-effects management) that are crucial for patients to complete treatment and recover. It argues that medical intervention alone is insufficient given the complex socio-economic and psychological context. C) Government's surveillance mechanism is deficient; and poor people have no access to treatment. While the passage hints at issues like "lack of adequate support from providers" and "expensive treatment," it does not primarily focus on the government's surveillance mechanism. It also doesn't state that poor people have *no access* to treatment, but rather highlights barriers to *continuing* treatment. This option is too specific and doesn't capture the full breadth of the message. D) India will be free from diseases like TB only when its poverty alleviation programmes are effectively and successfully implemented. While the passage strongly links TB to poverty and suggests poverty alleviation is crucial, stating that *only* poverty alleviation will make India *free from diseases like TB* is an extreme claim. The passage highlights a multi-faceted problem, including medical adherence, stigma, and support, not just poverty. Option B is more direct in addressing the *process of curing TB* as described in the passage, which involves a holistic approach beyond just medical treatment. Therefore, option B is the most logical, rational, and crucial message conveyed, as it addresses the comprehensive nature of successful TB treatment beyond just medical aspects.
Reading Comprehension: A majority of the TB infected in India are poor and lack sufficient nutrition, suitable housing and have little understa

Related questions

More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.