Our urban bodies cannot possibly ensure sustainable delivery of water in our cities unless financing mechanisms are put in place. Water delivery requires heavy investment in collecting it from a natural source, treating it to make it potable, and laying a distribution network of pipes for delivery to the users. It also requires investments in sewerage infrastructure and sewage treatment plants so that the sewers can carry the wastewater to these plants to ensure that no untreated sewage is discharged back into natural water bodies. If our cities were rich enough to meet the entire cost, water could be delivered free. They are not. What is the most logical and crucial message conveyed by the passage?
- AUrban local bodies must recover costs through user chargesCorrect
- BUrban local bodies are not efficient enough to meet the water requirements of our cities
- CWater shortage in our cities is a perennial problem that cannot be solved
- DIn view of the water crisis in our cities, there is an urgent need to limit the population of cities by adopting an upper limit of population size.
Explanation
The passage clearly states that urban bodies cannot ensure sustainable water delivery "unless financing mechanisms are put in place" because water delivery and sewerage infrastructure require "heavy investment" and cities "are not" rich enough to meet the entire cost.
Analysis of options: A) Urban local bodies must recover costs through user charges. This option directly addresses the core problem identified in the passage: the lack of financing and the inability of cities to bear the entire cost. If cities cannot pay, and heavy investment is needed, then recovering costs from users through charges is a logical and crucial financing mechanism implied by the text.
B) Urban local bodies are not efficient enough to meet the water requirements of our cities. The passage focuses on the financial inability to invest in infrastructure, not on the inefficiency of urban local bodies. It states they "cannot possibly ensure sustainable delivery... unless financing mechanisms are put in place," which points to a financial constraint, not an operational one.
C) Water shortage in our cities is a perennial problem that cannot be solved. The passage discusses the cost and delivery of water, implying that with proper investment, sustainable delivery is possible. It does not suggest the problem is unsolvable or inherently due to a physical water shortage that cannot be addressed.
D) In view of the water crisis in our cities, there is an urgent need to limit the population of cities by adopting an upper limit of population size. The passage discusses the financial requirements for infrastructure, not a population-driven resource crisis or a need to limit population. This is an unsupported inference.
Therefore, the most logical and crucial message is that financial mechanisms, such as user charges, are essential to cover the heavy costs of water delivery and treatment, as cities themselves cannot bear the full burden.

Related questions
More UPSC Prelims practice from the same subject and topic.
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
In India, over the last decade or so, labour has been departing agriculture, but is only going to construction and unregistered manufacturing which are not markedly better jobs. Services, where labour…
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
In India, the current focus on the right to privacy is based on some new realities of the digital age. A right is a substantive right only if it works in all situations, and for everyone. A right to f…
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
One of the biggest ironies around water is that it comes from rivers and other wetlands. Yet it is seen as divorced from them. While water is used as a resource, public policy does not always grasp th…
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
Asset allocation is the most important investment decision we will ever make, and sadly, most of us do not give that decision the importance it deserves. We are adamant about seeking predictability wi…
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
Although most of the Genetically Modified (GM) crops cultivated now are genetically engineered for a single trait, in future, crops genetically engineered for more than one trait will be the norm. Thu…
- Prelims 2020CSATReading Comprehension
Although most of the Genetically Modified (GM) crops cultivated now are genetically engineered for a single trait, in future, crops genetically engineered for more than one trait will be the norm. Thu…